A Senior Catholic Military Leader Speaks Out Against the Iran War
Archbishop Timothy Broglio, the most senior Catholic military cleric in the United States, has raised concerns about the justification for the ongoing conflict with Iran. In a recent interview, he criticized the administration’s decision to launch strikes against Iran, arguing that the action does not align with the principles of just war theory.
Broglio, who leads the Archdiocese for the Military Services and is known as one of America’s most conservative bishops, expressed his views on CBS’s Face the Nation. He described Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s use of religious rhetoric to justify the war as problematic. According to Broglio, the administration’s rationale for the conflict is based on the threat of nuclear weapons, which he claims Iran does not actually possess.
Just War Theory and Moral Permissibility
The concept of just war theory, developed by Saint Augustine, outlines conditions under which war can be morally justified. It states that war should only be considered when it is necessary to punish wrongdoing or defend the innocent, and always with the goal of restoring peace rather than seeking revenge or conquest. Broglio argued that the current situation does not meet these criteria.
He pointed out that the administration’s justification relies on a perceived threat that has not yet materialized. “While there was a threat with nuclear arms, it’s compensating for a threat before the threat is actually realized,” Broglio said.
Guidance for Troops and Military Leaders
Broglio encouraged military personnel to minimize harm while carrying out their orders, acknowledging that lower ranks may not have the authority to disobey commands unless they are clearly immoral. He also suggested that higher-ranking officers might have more flexibility to question the decisions made by leadership.
“Would generals or admirals have space to perhaps say, ‘Can we look at this a different way’? But having spoken to some of them, they are also in the same dilemma,” he said. “My counsel would be to do as little harm as you can and to try and preserve innocent lives.”
Conscientious Objection and Religious Rhetoric
Under U.S. military rules, troops may seek non-combat duty or discharge on grounds of conscientious objection, but they must continue to follow orders until any application is approved. Broglio expressed skepticism about Hegseth’s frequent references to Jesus Christ during discussions about the war.
“It’s a little bit problematic in the sense that, the Lord Jesus certainly brought a message of peace and also, I think, war is always a last resort,” Broglio said. He noted that while Hegseth may have had information leading him to believe war was the only option, he could not judge the situation without full knowledge.
The Pope’s Perspective and Religious Criticism
Broglio also referenced the views of Pope Leo, who quoted the Book of Isaiah in a rebuke of those who wage war. “God does not listen to the prayers of those who wage war, but rejects them,” Leo said, quoting Isaiah: “Even though you make many prayers, I will not listen: your hands are full of blood.”
Hegseth, a born-again evangelical Christian, has faced criticism for his religious rhetoric surrounding the conflict. He has prayed for “overwhelming violence” against enemies and framed operations in Biblical language, citing Psalm 144: “Blessed be the Lord, my rock, who trains my hands for war, and my fingers for battle.”


White House Response and Justification for the Conflict
In response to Broglio’s comments, the White House defended the administration’s actions. Spokeswoman Anna Kelly praised Trump’s “courageous” war against Iran, stating that eliminating threats posed by the Iranian regime is a humanitarian effort.
“There is nothing more humanitarian than eliminating the short- and long-term threats posed by the terrorist Iranian regime, which has targeted civilians throughout the region and long committed egregious human rights abuses against their own people,” she said.
Kelly added that past presidents have discussed taking action against the regime for 47 years, but Trump’s decision to dismantle its ballistic missile capacity, navy, and ability to arm proxies represents a significant step toward peace through strength.
















































