Urgent Need for Stricter Cyber Security Oversight in New Zealand’s Health Sector
Recent significant health data breaches have prompted the New Zealand government to unveil a new cybersecurity strategy and action plan. This national framework aims to bolster defences against escalating cyber threats, with a particular focus on critical infrastructure sectors including electricity, transport, financial payment systems, and crucially, the health sector. While consultations with these sectors are underway, a pressing argument emerges for enhanced regulatory oversight, especially within healthcare.
The vulnerability of sensitive patient information has been starkly highlighted by recent events. Late last year, the personal medical records of over 120,000 New Zealanders were compromised when the patient data portal, Manage My Health, fell victim to a cyberattack. This was followed in February by the disruption of the prescription app MediMap, which was taken offline after patient information within its system was found to have been tampered with. These incidents have not only caused significant concern but have also eroded public trust in New Zealand’s entire health system. Investigations are currently being conducted by the government and the Privacy Commissioner to understand the full scope of these breaches and to prevent future occurrences.
To effectively safeguard patient data and restore confidence, a fundamental shift in regulatory approach is required. It is argued that all entities involved in holding, transferring, or sharing health data, irrespective of whether they operate in the public or private sector, must be subjected to stringent regulatory oversight and mandatory audits.
Navigating the Complex Landscape of Health Data Security
From a public perspective, the distinction between a public healthcare provider and its private IT service provider is largely irrelevant when it comes to data security. The Privacy Act, in section 11, reinforces this by stating that healthcare providers remain accountable for information handled on their behalf, even when outsourced to IT service providers. However, a clause within the Health Information Privacy Code also designates IT providers as “health agencies,” creating potential ambiguity regarding ultimate responsibility.
A significant gap in New Zealand’s current legal framework is the absence of a single piece of legislation mandating enforceable minimum cybersecurity requirements. Beyond general privacy and security obligations, there are no explicit, legally binding due-diligence requirements in primary legislation concerning the selection of IT services. This deficiency needs to be addressed urgently.
Current Challenges in Health Data Management
The persistent issue of historical health data management presents a significant challenge. When patients switch doctors, their old medical records do not simply vanish. Instead, they can remain stored on the systems used by their previous practices for many years. Anecdotal evidence suggests instances where patient files were still being uploaded to platforms like Manage My Health, even two years after the practice had ceased using the service.
While healthcare providers are legally obligated to protect and manage this information, the current system lacks sufficient proactive auditing mechanisms. Patients are often not informed of potential vulnerabilities unless or until a serious incident materialises. To counter this, section 11 of the Privacy Act should be strengthened to necessitate clear, auditable contractual commitments between data holders and those acting on their behalf for storing or processing information.
Government agencies in New Zealand are already bound by strict protective security requirements that dictate how sensitive information must be handled. If data warrants this level of protection when held by government departments, it should logically receive equivalent protection when managed by external contractors.
International Best Practices in Healthcare Data Protection
Other nations have implemented robust measures to ensure the security of patient data. In the United Kingdom, any public or private organisation that accesses patient data held within the public health system is required to complete an annual mandatory data security and protection toolkit. Similarly, in the United States, healthcare providers are subject to federal audits under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA).
Finland provides a compelling example of swift and decisive action following a data breach. In response to a 2020 incident at the private psychotherapy centre Vastaamo, which exposed the sensitive, unencrypted records of 33,000 patients, Finland mandated security audits for all healthcare providers without exception. Investigations into the Vastaamo breach revealed critical vulnerabilities, including weak administrator access controls, inadequate network restrictions, and a lack of effective external security audits. Since implementing strengthened and broadened mandatory external security audits for all entities handling patient information, Finland has not reported any breaches of a similar magnitude. New Zealand would be well-advised to adopt a comparable approach.
As New Zealand awaits the findings of the ongoing government review and inquiry into recent breaches, several key areas warrant serious consideration:
Key Considerations for Enhanced Data Security
-
Data Storage and Sovereignty: The location of data storage can have significant implications. If data is housed on servers owned by foreign entities, foreign laws may apply, irrespective of the physical location of the servers. This is a particularly pertinent consideration when discussing the implications for Māori data sovereignty.
-
Due Diligence and Mandatory Oversight: Government agencies must adhere to clear and auditable processes before entrusting private vendors with sensitive patient data. All private companies that handle sensitive health information are already classified as health agencies and are expected to comply with the Health Information Privacy Code 2020. Providing clear guidance to doctors and health providers will be essential to assist them in making informed decisions about entrusting patient data to private companies.
-
Historic Data Management: Current regulations governing the retention and deletion of health data are dispersed across various legislative codes, and the ability to have data deleted can be limited. There is a clear need for greater transparency and enhanced supervision across the entire health data ecosystem.
The overarching argument is for New Zealand to implement mandatory security audits for all healthcare data systems. It is hoped that the government will prioritise and enforce such measures to safeguard the sensitive information of its citizens.















































